by E.D. Menasche
August 1995 Vol. 7 No. 4
pp. 22-31, 137
If you were forced to describe the musical mutant that is Primus, there are a few things that you
could say certainly: Primus is a trio from the Bay Area made up of bassist/vocalist Les Claypool,
guitarist Larry "Ler" LaLonde and drummer Tim "Herb" Alexander, all of whom speak English.
Primus' fourth album, 1993's Pork Soda (Interscope), sold nearly one million copies. Beyond
that, it gets a little tricky.
Unlike some of the bands that have been lumped into the increasingly mainstream and
forumalic "alternative" music category, Primus has enjoyed commercial and critical success by
flouting all conventions - even those set by the establishment's rules of non-conformity. Perhaps
they should have their very own genre, one where acrobatic chops meet the visceral intensity of
punk, and where the bass steps out of its traditional supporting role into the domain of featured
But regardless of what musical category they are forcibly jammed into, one thing is
certain: their latest effort, Tales from the Punchbowl (Interscope), is a breakthrough album. The
trio paints a deep and often dark aural landscape that underscores Claypool's skewed lyrical voice
like a soundtrack in a theater of the absurd. It's the visual, evocative quality that Primus plans to
exploit by releasing Punchbowl on both conventional audio-only CD and the new CD+ format,
which will allow them to include animated visuals with their music for the first time. [CD+ can be
played on CD-ROM and standard CD players - GS Ed.] There are also plans for a fullblown CD-
ROM in the works.
In addition to being a multi-media milestone for the band, Punchbowl also represents some
thing of a coming-out party for guitarist LaLonde, who may well have the most challenging job in
rock: trying to find an open playing space in the dense and intense musical arena dominated by
Claypool's bass. While Claypool's dizzying style, violently percussive textures are still on display,
LaLonde's guitar has a distinct, forceful presence, from the call and response that kicks off
"Professor Nutbutter's House of Treats", to the stinging King Crimsonesque phrasing of "On The
Tweak Again." This new balance is not accidental. "We got a much stronger tone for Larry, just
from having the time and freedom to work at my house," explained Claypool, who produced the
project at his digital home studio, The Corn. "It gives us a chance to get the sound we hear in our
head onto tape."
In truth, Claypool's budding career as a producer (Charlie Hunter, Marc "Mirv" Haggard,
and his own side-project Sausage) and record company owner (Prawn Song) might invite
comparisons to another singular soul, Frank Zappa. Which brings us back to our task of
describing this band and its members... ah, never mind.
Guitar School: Punchbowl seems to feature more guitar than prior Primus efforts. Was there a
concerted effort to give Larry more space to open up?
Les Claypool: Poor Larry has to deal with Herb and I being pretty aggressive players. Also, we
usually write from the bass and drums. By the time Ler gets around to doing his parts, there's not
necessarily a lot of space left.
Larry LaLonde: Usually, my role is to try to find what space there is and fill it up.
Claypool: We're not a band that plays much in unison. We do a lot of syncopation, things that
play off each other, and none of us like to have our toes stepped on. [laughs] But I pushed Larry
to assert himself a little bit more on this record. There was time to do that because we recorded
at my house and there wasn't the pressure of the studio clock ticking away. Next to my studio,
there's a little game room with a pool table and speakers that run in from the control room. We
were able to shoot pool and listen while Larry was doing his guitar tracks. Every so often, we
would peek our heads in and go, "Hey, that part sounded cool."
GS: The new album has an improvisational quality. Did you record much of it live?
LaLonde: Not really, actually...
Claypool: The three of us jammed at rehearsal and came up with general ideas, then Herb and I
started laying things down on our own. The arrangements were based on whatever vocal
melodies I had come up with at the time.
LaLonde: they would just record, and Les would say, "O.K., that's done." Herb would be like,
"That's an actual song?" [laughs]. After that, I'd just go in and throw the guitar stuff over the top.
Claypool: Usually, a full performance made it to tape with very little punching in, give or take a
solo or something. That kept the flow natural, as opposed to the way many people record, which
is to do piece work.
GS: Larry, do you have a strong idea of what you're going to play ahead of time?
LaLonde: Usually, I have no idea. I'll be sitting and listening while those are recording and I'll
start to hear something in my head. But everything seems to change once I hear the vocals. I
always have Les put down a vocal, even a scratch track, before play anything. I try to match the
mood of the lyrics.
GS: The guitar on "Professor Nutbutter's House Of Treats" roams all over the place.
LaLonde: The song cam out of a jam tape. It was pretty noisy in the practice room, so I couldn't
really tell what key it was in, what was going on - or anything! There's a complete Robert Flipp
rip-off going on, which comes from me feeling like everything was going crazy, I was like, "O.K.,
I'm just going to play." I thought I'd pick one note and start from there.
GS: So how does a nice boy from a Death Metal band like Possessed end up playing in Primus?
It must be quite an adjustment.
LaLonde: When I first got into Primus, my dream was to be in a band that was sort of a cross
between Frank Zappa and the Dead Kennedys. But my God, at this point, it's like I don't know
what's going on. [laughs] I think all the influences of all the people I've ever listened to are just
gone. I just try to play what I can.
GS: Just who are these influences you speak of?
LaLonde: My favorite guitar player ever is Frank Zappa. When I think of what makes a good
guitar solo, Zappa's playing is the thing I think of. It's the ultimate example of how a guitar
GS: I think his guitar playing is under-recognized.
LaLonde: Most people probably don't even know he played guitar! Snakefinger's another guy I
like. All the harmonizer stuff I've ever done - people think it's this real guitar-head rock thing - I
got it all from him. [Sometime Resident cohort and Vestal Virgins bandleader Philip
"Snakefinger" Lithman passed away in 1987 - GS Ed.]
GS: Your playing on "On The Tweak Again" reminds me of Adrian Belew's work with King
Crimson - your phrasing has that twisted horn-like quality that manages to be jarring and fluid at
the same time.
LaLonde: I love listening to horn players. It's such a human instrument. Guitar can be kind of
GS: I guess that depends on whether someone is just playing fast for the sake of doing it or doing
so to serve the music. I still think Steve Vai's playing on P.I.L.'s album [Virgin] is the prime
example of incredible technique being harnessed for the good of the song.
LaLonde: It's always cool to hear people who are super-talented and can really play use their
technique to play music as opposed to show how fast they are. But hey, I used to listen to
Yngwie. I had his demos. But by the time he actually put out an album, it was like, "Ah, fuck
GS: The thing about developing incredible technique is that you can spend the rest of your life
learning how to use it.
Claypool: Exactly, I've always been a pretty aggressive player, and as a young player I was
obnoxiously aggressive - it was all about chops. And I think that's the way most young players
are. It took three years of playing two-to-five nights in an R&B bar band with some older players
to get me to calm down and learn the importance of grooving and establishing a foundation.
GS: You've been described as a "lead bass" player, but you seem to play the role of the rhythm
guitarist as well.
Claypool: Well, being in a trio, I always felt I had to come up with the bass part and some other
"rhythm guitar" type part just to fill space - especially since I was writing the bulk of the tunes. I
don't really think of the bass the way most people do. To me, it's a form of expression, the tool I
use to get what I hear in my head out into the world. If I was playing Ocarina or Oboe or
something, it would be the same.
GS: Larry, isn't it a challenge to work with a bass player who cover lead and rhythm roles
traditionally left to the guitarist?
LaLonde: At this point, it's actually pretty natural to me. Over the years, I've gotten used to being
more of a textural player. In a way, it gives me more freedom - I can play whatever I want
because I don't have to lock into structured parts all the time.
GS: You guys seem to trade roles in a few places, with Les playing fluid lines and Larry playing
Claypool: I've always been very rhythm-oriented, but I'm starting to develop more melodic part.
"De Anza Jig," "Southbound Pachyderm" and "Over The Electric Grapevine" are all more melodic
than things I've done in the past. I find it kind of exciting. I've never really had that aspect in my
playing - even when I've soloed, I've never really played melodies as much as percussive rhythm
pieces. In fact, I play drums a lot, which helps me with singing and playing the bass at the same
time - the drums help me get more independence.
GS: Your lyrics are much more character-driven and narrative than the average pop song's, which
gives strong visual component - do you listen to much theatrical music?
Claypool: Ever since I was a kid listening to my old Disney and Mother Goose records, musical
and songs, I've loved music that tells some sort of story or fable. Even now, I love any music that
sets a mood or brings forth mental pictures, like Tom Watts, or the Residents, or a [Oingo Boingo
vocalist] Danny Elfman soundtrack.
GS: some of the characters that you create are comic, but also a little scary. Mrs. Blaileen comes
to mind. What is she all about?
Claypool: She's the sixth-grade teacher of Don, the young lad picked on.
GS: Do you think people like her need to be poked fun at?
Claypool: Oh, I tend to poke fun at just about anything that comes along. A lot of my existence is
steeped in satire and humor. We like to have a good time. We like to rib each other and rib
others, and take things with a grain of sugar. My philosophy is, "laugh as often as you can." It's
good therapy. But, you know, not everything is pretty and happy. Humor is a good defense and
GS: The music business takes itself so seriously - I always felt that so much angst and teeth
gnashing is at odds with the whole spirit of making music.
Claypool: It doesn't have to be that way. But there is a strong tendency in the music business -
and in any other forms of art - not to take humor seriously. People look down on Frank Zappa
because he was just to damn silly. I don't ever see our bent perspective as being a huge part of
the mainstream. But there's also a portion of people who enjoy this sort of obtuse look at the
world, and we're able to make a living at it, and I'm sure there'll be people after us doing the same
GS: Why do you assume the personality of the characters who inhabit your songs when you sing?
Claypool: It's easier for me to do that then to actually try and be a melodic singer with any type of
range or pitch.
GS: I understand you're both getting heavily involved with computers, and that Punchbowl will be
released as a CD+ as well as a regular audio-only CD. Are you planning to release any CD-
Claypool: Yes, the whole thing is still fairly undefined. Even the record company is trying to
figure out how to deal with it. But CD-ROM definitely gives us an opportunity to develop more
visual ideas for our tunes. I've always said I'd love to do a video for every song, because we have
visuals for them, but it's just not economically feasible, and MTV only plays what they feels like
playing. We've had some disappointing situations where we've come up with stuff, like the "Mr.
Krinkle" video, which I loved and poured my heart into; it got played like three times. With the
CD+, we can come up with visuals for every song and get into them without more sitting down in
interviews and saying,"Well, this song is about this!"
LaLonde: I've been a complete computer-head for like two years now, and CD+ is great for me,
because anything that gets me behind a computer makes me happy.
Claypool: Larry and I sat in front of computers all day for two and a half weeks working on cover
artwork. There are so many different colors on the record and the cover artwork seemed bland in
contrast. We were supposed to go to Disneyland and hang out with Danny Elfman and relax after
the five-an-a-half month recording grind, but decided we had to do something with the art. We
began coming up with these different things for the cover - basically an album cover for every
song. Now we have a ton of art - a lot of 3-D art and a lot of visuals - we can expand on for the
GS: Are you filming or animating?
LaLonde: Mostly animating. I find anything that's too "real life"to be kind of weird on the
computer. It's so silly right now, because you're only seeing 265 colors. The CD medium is kind
of lame. It's so slow. And any CD-ROM you put out has to run on the slowest computers out
there. Which sucks, 'cause [assuming manly voice] I have a fast computer, I actually have several
Power Macintoshes. But you know how computers are - you can be on the cuttin' edge and, in
two weeks, it's like you're in the stone age.
GS: The computer seems like it could make music and musicians more accessible to people.
LaLonde: Going on-line gives fans a chance to leave messages fro the bands and, obviously,
bands are going to read the stuff. We'll eventually have a whole Primus site. You'll be able to
upload music, which will be really cool once the platform gets faster.
GS: Plus you get all this bizarre news, perfect for your lyrical story-mill. Someone sent me a
download about this guy who didn't like his laxative, so he wrote in for a refund. Instead of
sending him two dollars, the company sent him like $98,000 - they put his zipcode on the check
by accident. So he cashed it and took off, and now the police are looking for him.
LaLonde: No way! That actually ties in with the story I'm writing [laughs] Me and friends were
talking about doing this wacky computer movie thing. It's about these guys who go to jury duty,
and instead of getting 10 dollars, they'll get $10,000.
GS: Will you be integrating your work with computers in your live show?
LaLonde: At the last Lollapalooza, we had a big movie screen at the back of the stage, like a big
drive-in. I always liked some of the stuff Pink Floyd did, even though these days it's not really
that hip to have a big show or do something like that; you're just supposed to go out there and
pretend you're punk rock, I guess. But we're hoping to do some cool stuff for our next tour.
GS: Moving from computers to musical equipment, what kind of gear are you using these days?
Claypool: I picked up a six-string fretted bass toward the end of recording Pork Soda, and used it
on that album for "DMV" and "Hamburger Train." You just plug in and it has this huge, amazing
tone that's right on the verge of clipping and farting and being so ugly, but has this fullness to it. I
used it extensively on Punchbowl. "Mrs. Blaileen", "Professor Nutbutter," the "Year Of The
Parrot"... I have a feeling I'll be using it a lot more live, because it's so comfortable to play. The
guy who built it, Carl Thompson, claims it's the first six-string ever made in the world. He had it
sitting around his house and never liked it because the neck was so thin. I asked him to put some
outlandishly light strings on it and lay frets into the neck. The upper strings are actually unwound,
like guitar strings. You can bend them - they sound almost like a Strat or something - really
trippy. You've got this fat bottom and this tiny upper end. It comes alive.
LaLonde: I play a Paul reed Smith most of the time, especially live. I even use it for slide. I never
like changing my guitar on stage. I used a PRS on all but two songs on the album The two that I
play most often are set neck models; a 24-fret Vintage-Yellow Maple-Top and a Custom 24-fret
Walnut-Top. I just got two McCarthy models, and they're really cool, too. I also have some
interesting older guitars, including the one Hendrix used on "All Along The Watchtower." I have
a lot of stuff I got cheap in pawn-shops, like a cool Van Epps 7-string. I totally stole a Gibson
345 from this one place. They were like, [assuming serious cracker accent] "That thing's been
sittin' on the wall for years. I can't believe you'd want to buy it." I have a Gibson 150-E, which is
like a big, fat 355, a National Airline, which has racing stripes on it, and five Strats, most of them
from 1979. There's something about that vintage that just does it for me.
GS: And you can find them for cheap. A friend of mine bought one from an ex-girlfriend for
LaLonde: [laughing] You're not going to believe this, but I actually got the Hendrix guitar from
an ex-girlfriend. Her dad worked with Hendrix. This guitar is on a lot of records: a Clapton
album, a Greatful Dead album, a Hot Tuna album.
GS: How about your amp set-ups?
Claypool: same old stuff:: Boogie cabinets and a ADA MP-2 preamp. On the record, I just fed
the board with the preamp. I didn't really go for a lot of fancy stuff. I used the ADA just to cut
some highs and add some lows. I don't use many effects, except a little chorus now and then.
LaLonde: I usually use a pair of Marshall 50-watt half-stacks. But I have about a zillion amps,
from every year you could think of, each with its own sound. When we went to do this record, I
pulled them out of the closet. The whole theory behind this band is to preserve a live feeling, as
opposed to setting up a new sound for each song, and I wanted to find an amp that sounded clean
when you cranked it. This way I could get all my sounds from stomp boxes. I ended up using an
early 1x12 Mesa/Boogie combo. I have a very early Fender Twin that's in mint condition. It's
just one of those amps: you turn everything all the way up, and it just has that sound. I also have
this 1x15 Maestro amp, which is this blue sparkly thing that looks like and old Gibson Falcon
And then I have piles an piles of effects, too many to name. I'd just start plugging and
unplugging things. My main sound was an Electro-Harmonix Hot Tubes, going through that
Boogie, or sometimes through an old Ampeg Portaflex. The super-distorted, crazy stuff is usually
the Boss Metal Zone pedal with the wacky EQ in it. I used some harmonizer on "Professor
Nutbutter," as well... I hope you're going to edit this to make it look like I know what I am
GS: I am going to edit it so it looks like I know what I am talking about.
LaLonde: Put a lot of stuff about strings and picks in there.
GS: What kind of picks do you use?
LaLonde: I use whatever are the coolest ones are.
GS: So, in truth, your ultimate go is to be cool?
LaLonde: Yeah. Put a lot of stuff in there about how shred is uncool, and then we'll be totally hip.
And put something in there about me saying something bad about Yngwie. These days, that's
how you become cool in a guitar magazine.
Any Questions or Comments
Brian Savage /